The Black Midnight
by Kathleen Y’Barbo
My rating: 3 / 5
Genre: Historical romance, crime
Pinkerton detective Alice Anne, great-granddaughter to Queen Victoria, investigated a series of murders in Austin, Texas in 1884, along with her partner Isaiah Joplin. The perpetrator was never caught, but the pair team up four years later to try to solve a similar series of murder in the Whitechapel district of London. Are the killers the same, and will a culprit be caught for either case?
I think the biggest issue with this book was in the subject matter. Each of the books in the True Colors series focuses on a different true crime from history, with real historical facts melded with fictional characters and situations. The difficulty, though, is in making an interesting, fulfilling story out of a crime that was never solved, as is the case with the real murders this book is set around. While I understand the author’s desire not to make up a conclusion that didn’t really happen, I think I would have preferred fictionalized closure to the “we really don’t know anything,” hemming & hawing mess this book devolved into.
As the detectives investigate, we are constantly presented with theories followed by, “But maybe not.” Over and over, this is all that happens in the case. It made the story feel slow and pointless, and as if the entire investigation was just a wash (which I realize might have been how the real investigators felt back then, but it doesn’t make for interesting fiction). My favorite example of this is said by the queen herself: “‘The truth always has its day,’ Granny said with a shrug. ‘Until it does not.'” What is even the point of making a statement like that?
There were some strange inconsistencies throughout the book too–for example, early in the book it says that Alice Anne (known as Annie for most of the book) was using an American accent, I assume to blend in, since she was keeping her identity a secret. But later in the book, a reporter muses about the oddity of this Pinkerton detective with the British accent. This is one example of a few things that made me stop and look back to see if I’d missed or mis-remembered something.
Overall, the book was a quick read, but not a very satisfying one for me. The ending was muddled and felt very rushed, after a climax that I don’t even get the purpose of. I think a majority of what I disliked about the book was due to the unsolved crime it was based around, but like with a previous True Colors book I read, perhaps this was simply a bad choice for the subject of a fictional romance book. I found it difficult to care about the relationship, and especially the culmination of the romantic storyline, because the rest of the book was so confusing and underwhelming.
Thank you to Netgalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc. for providing me a copy of this book to review.
Find out more about The Black Midnight
If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!
3 thoughts on “Book Review: The Black Midnight”
Uh… Pinkerton working in London? Back then? I doubt it. Sounds a bit strange to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s the fault of my really boiled-down synopsis. They were both Pinkertons in America initially. By the time the London murders happened, neither were actually working as Pinkertons anymore. However, at the beginning of the book, the queen asks Annie to investigate, due to her time spent as a detective, and Annie recruits her former partner and brings him to London.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah… still… seems a bit far fetched to me.