Book Review: Faithfully Dissident Daughters

Faithfully Dissident Daughters
by Chelsea Kim Long

My rating: 0 / 5
Genre: Christian non-fiction

I’m not going to pretend that I didn’t have some concerns about this book before I started reading it. When I was offered an ARC, I thought it wouldn’t hurt to see what Chelsea Kim Long had to say about Christian womanhood. However, this is not a Christian book. This is a pagan book masquerading as a Christian book. That may be a bold claim to make, and I’m sure many won’t agree with me. I’ll sum up my review below with this: Long denies the sin of Adam and Eve, the fall and the curse that was then passed on to all future generations, that we are all born into, and the very reason we needed a perfect, sacrificial Lamb to die for us.

Quoted from the book: “In the beginning, God created humanity and called it good, a reflection of the image of God. Yet somehow, much of mainstream Christian culture paints our humanity in a negative light” (pg. 14). But we paint our humanity in a negative light because of what came after God called us good. Adam and Eve disobeyed God and brought the curse of sin on all humanity thereafter. She spends pages picking apart Jeremiah 17:9—”The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it?” (ESV)—because she doesn’t want to think of her heart as “bad.” She says she no longer sees herself as a sinner with a “deceitful” heart. Which is 100% unbiblical. What about Romans 3:23, which says that all have sinned? Does her new version of the Bible say “all but women have sinned”? “All but feminists”? “All but those who decide to deconstruct their faith”?

Long grew up in a church that might not have been the most helpful for a child learning about God, if she was taught that a woman is only seen as godly if she gets married and has kids (in natural homebirths, apparently). I have to admit that the Jeremiah verse I mentioned earlier wouldn’t be the first one I’d drill into the head of a new believer of any age, which apparently happened to her. She seems to still want to call herself a Christian, but I’m not sure why she bothers. If it weren’t for the sin of Adam and Eve, there would have been no reason for Christ to die and be resurrected. (Seriously, why would anyone go through all of that without very good reason?!) More personally for Long, if she doesn’t see herself as sinful, then she doesn’t need Christ or his redemptive work, and what would it even mean to be a Christian then?

Long defends what she’s doing here against anyone who might claim that she’s in the wrong by telling us to look at her fruit. Because yes, in Matthew 7:17-18, Jesus says, “So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit. A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit” (ESV). On the other hand, she also claims that, “The fruit of the Spirit is not something you have to work to attain. Love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control already exist within you…” (pg. 18, emphasis mine). Note that this is the fruit of the Spirit, meaning the Holy Spirit, i.e. God, not the fruit of humanity. It does not already exist within us; only God is good! The fruit I’m seeing from Chelsea Kim Long is this book in which she encourages readers to interpret the Bible however they see fit and proceeds to do so for us to a scary degree. Since it’s pretty clear that Long doesn’t believe that the Bible is 100% accurate, I guess I shouldn’t be surprised by anything she says in this book. She also clearly doesn’t believe God is sovereign, or she would trust that He could have kept His Word protected to make sure that important concepts weren’t completely left out or skewed so badly that only a sect of deconstructionists could uncover the real meaning.

Here are some further examples of the ways that Long has managed to make the Bible fit her own ideas, in brief. (I know some of these aren’t as important to all Christians as they are to me, but I’m still going to include them all.) The author/the book:

• is pro-abortion
• is against God’s plan for gender and sexuality
• is pro-evolution (at least implied)
• skews God to be female
• is pro-yoga and other New Age/mystic beliefs
• is pro-idol worship (at least implied)

Let me talk about that last one in more detail. On page 27, Long talks favorably about people who used to worship female gods, claiming that it wasn’t until later that the Hebrew scriptures turned religion into a patriarchy. But since God existed before the universe was created, God refers to himself using male terms in the Bible (Father, Son, etc.), and “All Scripture is breathed out by God” (2 Timothy 3:16 ESV), it is 100% unbiblical to claim that people were worshiping female gods before men came along and forced a change. Beyond that, though, my basis for saying that the author/book is pro-idol worship is because taking what you don’t like out of the Bible/Christianity and making it what you want is setting up your own religion. Your own idols. Full stop.

I do understand that men have treated women badly throughout history and plenty of them back up their actions using the Bible. But people in general have used the Bible incorrectly to back up all sorts of terrible, violent, sinful behaviors, not only in the male vs. female arena. This is because the world is fallen, not because God isn’t sovereign or the Bible isn’t true. Anyone who deconstructs Christianity and removes the sovereignty of God, the authority of the Bible, sin, and the need for a Savior is left with…nothing. Certainly nothing resembling Christianity. And that’s what we have here. Please be aware of that if you decide to read this book. In case it’s not clear, I not only don’t recommend this book to anyone, I would actively warn against it. For any Christian women who are looking for books about true biblical womanhood, I would recommend Made to Be She by Kristen Clark & Bethany Beal instead.

I received an advanced review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Find out more about Faithfully Dissident Daughters

See what’s coming up.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Home Fires

Home Fires
by Mally Ham

My rating: 5 / 5
Genre: Memoir, Christian non-fiction

Ken and Mally Ham have been married for over 50 years, and for much of that time, Ken has traveled all over to teach people about Genesis, creation, and biblical truths that have been under attack for decades. In this book, Mally shares the ups and downs of their lives together, her perspective on the beginnings and growth of Answers in Genesis, and how God provided what she needed throughout it all. I am so grateful for and appreciative of what AIG has taught me over the years through its various resources and the ministry’s commitment to the truth, so seeing the incredible ways God opened the doors for it to become what it is today didn’t surprise me at all. I enjoyed the additions from Mally’s children and some other family members; it grounds the book in a way, showing that Mally’s humility is not exaggerated. I truly loved getting this behind-the-scenes look at their family, and it made the entire book an absolute joy to read.

The primary audience for the book seems mainly to be wives of men in ministry, but there is also a lot to glean about godly marriages in general. Though many of us won’t have the same personality as Mally (I share her incredible shyness, but not her humility and gentleness, at least not naturally), she does offer insight that goes beyond her own experiences. As someone preparing to enter ministry life alongside my husband, I found her perspective incredibly comforting and deeply encouraging. This book is a great read for Christian women or anyone interested in the background of Answers in Genesis.

Find out more about Home Fires

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Life Is Hard. God Is Good. Let’s Dance.

Life Is Hard. God Is Good. Let’s Dance.
by Brant Hansen

My rating: 5 / 5
Genre: Christian living

It’s all right there in the title. Our world is fraught with anxiety, fear, and depression. But God truly is good, and understanding that truth can help us trade in the anxiety for peace and joy. Radio show host Brant Hansen offers insight, suggestions, and examples on this topic. He uses scripture as well as quotes from both Christian and secular writers and thinkers to back up his claims, and he does it all with his signature humor.

I have a lot of respect for Brant Hansen, his take on God and the Bible, and the ways he lives out his faith. He talks a lot about CURE International in this book, as people he’s met through that organization seem to have given him a lot of insight into the subject matter of this book. (I don’t mean this in a bad way, by the way, as CURE is a wonderful program and absolutely worthy of all of the attention he gives it.) Brant’s casual style makes the book easy to read and understand, which I appreciate so much. And because I listened to the audiobook, I got to hear it all in his own voice, which always adds a layer of enjoyment for me. Whichever way you go, I recommend this book, as well all of Brant Hansen’s books, really, to everyone.

Find out more about Life Is Hard. God Is Good. Let’s Dance. or The Brant & Sherri Oddcast

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Boreal Wilderland

Boreal Wilderland
by Robert Mullen

My rating: 4 / 5
Genre: Nonfiction, art

Robert Mullen brings together several different artists with paintings, sketches, and photographs of the North American boreal forest in this colorful, informative book. I enjoyed the descriptions of various expeditions into the wilderness and especially encounters with animals during these voyages. Canoeing through little-traveled areas and experiencing what few others experience is something I would loved to have done at some point in my life (it’s definitely not feasible for me anymore), and this book brings that to life. The artwork is breathtaking, and I’d imagine it’s even more so in print version, compared to the ebook I read (though thank goodness I at least have a decent-size tablet to do justice to the full-page spreads).

I’ll admit that I did skim some of the sections about different wildlife, when the information shared was about where they lived or nested and how endangered they were, paying more attention when the author shared personal experiences with certain species. My main issue, though, is with the extensive references to the world being billions of years old, which is pure conjecture but referenced here as fact (and often). It’s nothing I’m not used to and doesn’t keep the book from being beautiful and interesting. I could see this being a great gift for someone interested in the subject matter and is an overall enjoyable book.

I received a review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Find out more about Boreal Wilderland

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Empire and Frontier

Empire and Frontier
by Samuel Marquis

My rating: 3 / 5
Genre: History

Empire and Frontier follows Colonel Peter Schuyler in New York during King William’s War (1689–1701), showcasing alliances and conflicts with various Native American groups, the French, and other colonists. The language in the synopsis led me to think this might be a fictionalized story of this time in history, but it’s actually nonfiction. While that’s fine, it just wasn’t quite what I was looking for. Weirdly, though, there are moments where it becomes more subjective than I’d expect a history book to be, with the author attributing feelings and reflections to various people in the book—details I find difficult to believe are described to that degree in letters or journals. The author also seems to include some bias for or against some of the historical figures in the book, religions involved, things like that.

There’s a pretty in-depth list of all historical figures involved at the front of the book, which I mostly read through, but that turned out to be unnecessary, because the same details given there are also given each time one of those people is first introduced in the book. That and other repetitive sections caused me to start skimming the book in parts. The book would zoom out and cover several months quickly, and then zoom in and focus on a battle in detail, which made the flow a little hard to follow. I will say, though, that the battle descriptions were some of the most interesting parts in the book. I could have done without explanation of some of the ways people were “slow tortured” by their enemy though.

It’s not that I didn’t find anything of interest in the book, and I can definitely see it being fascinating to history buffs. If you’re looking for historical fiction, this isn’t that, but if you enjoy reading about history, are interested in this time period in American history, and are okay with some subjectivity by the author, then you may be the right audience for this book.

I received a review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Find out more about Empire and Frontier

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: So You Want To Be An Architect

So You Want to Be an Architect
by Linda Soules

My rating: 5 / 5
Genre: Middle grade nonfiction

So You Want to Be an Architect takes what could be a complicated subject and makes it accessible to kids and teens. But it also doesn’t talk down to them—there are areas younger kids may not be able to follow, but there’s enough context to get the point across well enough, I think. I also think that if something is a little over a kid’s head and sends them to asking someone about it or looking it up, that’s not a bad thing at all. The book goes beyond explaining what architects do and what they need to learn to be able to do it; it also talks about what kinds of interests, innate skills, and even indefinable ways of seeing the world around them that might lend themselves to a potential future architect. There are segments on famous architects and fun facts as well and beautiful, colorful illustrations throughout. (The illustrations are done with AI assistance, as Soules explains at the back of the book.)

I really like how the book talks about both the good and the bad (or at least the difficult) sides of being an architect, as well as the glamorous and more-common “normal” aspects. The book is intended for pre-teens through teens aged 10-14, and I definitely could see it being a great one for anyone in or near that age range, on either side of it.

Find out more about So You Want To Be An Architect

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Four Windows, One Jesus

Four Windows, One Jesus
by Chad Colter

My rating: 3 / 5
Genre: Christian devotional

Four Windows, One Jesus is a 40-day devotional focusing on Jesus as portrayed in the four gospels. Each gospel is given 10 days (11, if you count the intro to each gospel’s section that is about as long as the daily devotional), with the intention to show the different facets of Christ that are provided by the 4 different gospel writers.

I think many will find a lot to appreciate in this devotional. I wrote down a few nuggets that I gleaned and that made me think about Jesus, myself, or my relationship with Jesus a little differently. The author pushes the reader to not just skim passages that are familiar or even thought of as boring, like the genealogy at the beginning of Matthew, but to slow down and try to focus on the text and why it has been included. As someone who has been a Christian for many years and has read/heard passages from the gospels many times over the years, I appreciate this slower approach. I also like that the reader is tasked with reading a passage for themselves and then reading the devotional about that passage, rather than 1) the devotional covering only a verse or two, which can be done well, but often ends up feeling a little shallow or out of context (though there are a few of these devotionals that cover only a verse or two as well) or 2) feeding you the passage instead of leading you to look it up in your own Bible.

However, I struggled with a few aspects of the devotionals along the way. There is a lot of repetition in each devotional, and the author’s overall literary style is not my preference. He weirdly seems to pit one gospel/gospel writer against another when the day’s passage is one that is also included in another gospel, comparing them in a way that, at least to me, seems to say that the other one has parts to it that aren’t worth thinking about right now (even though the idea here is supposed to be to bring the different views of Christ together). And in the same way, he seems dismissive of the Old Testament and other historical context, as he will vaguely reference something that would give a scene in the gospel more depth and meaning and tell the reader to not let that bog down the reading/understanding. But as my church’s pastor is fond of saying, “There’s no text without context.” Sometimes that context makes all the difference in understanding why what happened in the gospel matters or what it means! There were a few spots I noted that I think he may have interpreted something wrongly, but nothing I felt was theologically wrong.

I am not sure who the audience for this devotional is meant to be. I feel that some of his vague references to context would confuse newer Christians or those who don’t have a decent background with the Bible. More mature Christians might find enough of value here to make the book worthwhile, so I suppose that’s where the correct audience is best found. I could see a case being made for reading this with a group, because good discussion about what is brought up in the text (and even the question about whether or not the reader should ignore the context or whether one angle of an account is “better” in Mark vs. Matthew) could arise.

I received a free review copy from the author in exchange for my honest unedited feedback.

Find out more about Four Windows, One Jesus

See what’s coming up.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Living Unoffended

Living Unoffended
by Brant Hansen

My rating: 4 / 5
Genre: Christian living

Radio show host Brant Hansen counters the common opinion that Christians are entitled to “righteous anger,” while also making a case about how learning to let go of our “right” to be offended can change our lives.

I read Unoffendable by Brant Hansen 6 years ago and found that it had a lot to offer; it helped me examine a lot in my life, not only about anger and anxiety but also hypocrisy and self-righteousness. As Brant says in the intro to this book, “We need to keep talking about this stuff.” Brant does a good job here of laying out why righteous anger doesn’t really make sense and how anger and worry mean we’re not trusting God like we should. He uses scripture as well as examples from both Christian and secular writers and thinkers to back up his claims, and he does it all with his signature humor. Brant also offers some practical advice for learning to let go of offense, becoming more humble and Christ-like, and trusting God more fully.

The book is basically a series of short essays, and some of the content comes from at least 2 of Brant’s other books (Unoffendable and Life Is Hard. God Is Good. Let’s Dance.). I haven’t read the 2nd of those books yet, and fortunately I read the 1st long enough ago that it didn’t feel like a repeat to me. However, if you have read either or both of those books, you may not feel the need to read this one. Not that there isn’t anything new here, but I’m not sure how much is new. I do recommend this book, as well all of Brant Hansen’s books, really, for Christians and non-Christians alike.

Thank you to Netgalley and W Publishing for providing me a copy of this book to review.

Find out more about Living Unoffended or The Brant & Sherri Oddcast

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Thinking Things Over

Thinking Things Over
by Charles Francis Guittard

My rating: 3.5 / 5
Genre: Memoir

There are 3 main styles within this book about two 80-year-olds meeting online and falling in love. First, there is a series of essays written by the author himself, Charles Francis Guittard, who is clearly very interested in history, especially that of his own family. The essays cover Guittard’s time growing up, focusing on what his parents both did to try to make him a well-rounded individual, with some included backstory of his parents’ lives. Then there’s a large middle sections that is a collection of emails between Guittard and his now-wife Nancy Davis Labastida, when they first met and got to know each other, all the way through about a week before their marriage. This covers only around 3 months, but includes a lot of emails. Finally, there’s a section of stories about Labastida’s tiime growing up in semi-interview format—Guittard asking questions for her to answer. The last section of the book is a fictional imagining of someone facing judgement upon their death, so I guess that’s sort of a 4th style, but that and the section about Labastida’s childhood are comparatively short.

Strangers to married in 3 months sounds crazy to most people, but I have to say that the amount of info they shared in their emails does make it a lot more understandable. I can also understand a desire to not wait very long to be with someone you feel so connected to, when you’re in your 80s. The emails read like two teenagers falling in love for the first time, though they had both been married before. There are parts of their romance that I did not connect with, but that’s not to say that made it bad somehow. Overall, I did enjoy the book more than I didn’t.

I question the inclusion of the short story at the end. It’s essentially a courtroom drama where God, Jesus, and the Holy Ghost are sitting in judgement over a man who claims to have lived a good life. There are 2 lawyers questioning making arguments and even questioning a couple of witnesses, but it leaves me really confused about what Guittard understands about salvation and eternity. He includes a lot of church lingo and seems to have a decent understanding of what is important to salvation, but at the same time, he seems confused as well. For one thing, the fictional defendant sort of claims that the Trinity is made-up, which he says to the panel made up of the triune God…so…that makes sense (unless he’s making the theological point that Jesus and the Holy Ghost aren’t God?). But more importantly, he talks about a “come to Jesus” moment vaguely and talks about denominations and baptism and tithing as if those are a big part of whether or not someone is saved. The question is simple: have you repented of your sins and accepted Jesus as Savior and Lord? I think the clear answer here for J. Hiram Harmless (the fictional defendant) is: no.

Though normally, I don’t have a lot of negative to say about an autobiography or memoir, understanding that the author has shared what they wanted to share, whether I wish there was more or less of anything. But, the dip into fiction aside, I will say, there are portions of this book that I had to skim. A lot was included about tennis and bridge, neither of which I’m particularly interested in (or know anything about at all, in the case of bridge). There are other personal details that I also skimmed, but I may just not be the right audience—I have a feeling that people interested in genealogy or personal family histories will enjoy those parts a lot more than I did.

Find out more about Thinking Things Over

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: Newsboy

Newsboy: My Story of Hope and Second Chances
by John James

My rating: 5 / 5
Genre: Memoir, Christian non-fiction

When John James first stepped down as the Newsboys lead singer in the late 90s, I was in high school. I had no idea what had led to this decision, but the band kept making great music, so I was content enough. Then, I remember very well the Newsboys concert my husband, son, and I attended (it had to have been around 2009-2011, since it was soon into the band’s new era), when John James stepped out onto the stage to talk. I’m pretty sure most of the people around us had no idea who he was, but I did. I had been to at least one concert before he left, owned several cassette tapes or CDs of the early Newsboys, and had seen Down Under the Big Top many times (I even had several of his lines memorized from the movie—still do, in fact, and still have the VHS tape). I hadn’t seen him in a long time and was excited he was there! He began to tell his story, talking about his addictions and sinful behavior that had led to his departure from the band. He talked about the moment he thought about killing himself, making a joke about it, and the people around us laughed. I didn’t find any humor in it, though; my husband and I stood there with mouths agape. I’m pretty sure I was holding back tears. I’m really glad I didn’t know about any of that back when I was a teen and the Newsboys was fasting becoming my favorite band (especially since the info circulating at the time was largely worse than the truth), only hearing some of the details after James had allowed Christ’s redemptive work to change his heart and his life.

This book expands a lot on what he shared during that concert over 10 years ago, and James is transparent and vulnerable in the text, not hiding or sugarcoating his choices and downward spiral. He starts with his childhood, a foundation that shows that he wasn’t just paying lip service to Christian tenets when he first started writing songs and speaking on stage as the frontman of the band. But like all of us who are sinners saved by grace, he made wrong choices, which he then compounded with more wrong choices and the decision to hide those choices from friends and loved ones. He talks of danger points, like disconnecting from a local church and neglecting one’s personal time with God, and he ends the book with a very hopeful note. I don’t think I’d call it a “happy ending,” exactly, because he is still suffering some consequences from how he lived for a while. But the major theme here, which is infused throughout the book, is that God can redeem those that are lost and is waiting to do so, if we’ll turn and repent. This book is definitely worth reading for anyone who is a fan of the Newsboys (in any iteration), is interested in stories about the Christian music industry, or is in a position where you believe you’ve fallen too far to be forgiven by God.

Find out more about Newsboy

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!