procedural

Book Review: Luck and Judgement

/ Kristi / Leave a comment

Luck and Judgement
DC Smith #3
by Peter Grainger
read by Gildart Jackson

My rating: 4.5 / 5
Genre: Detective procedural, mystery

When a man disappears from an offshore gas platform, it’s unclear whether foul play was involved or not. DC Smith and his team’s investigation leads them to some seedy parts of their town and involves some powerful people.

I think this was my favorite of the series so far, even if it did involve some very questionable elements, from a “married singles” club to DC’s own decision to bend the rules (quite a bit, really) for a matter unrelated to the case. Plus, the case was left a bit dangling at the end, but it’s really just a lack of a satisfying resolution. For all intents and purposes, we have an ending, just maybe not one we’d like. I don’t know if this will be continued in future books, but I could see it as a possibility, since cases from previous books are brought up here and there in this book as well.

DC is such a nuanced character, it’s difficult to get a handle on him. But I mean that in a good way. He feels a lot more realistic that way. I enjoy his ribbing with Waters yet also being stern when needed. And him being understanding with a new member of his team that has had a bit of a colorful and rough background. And the further crumbs we get about his history before the start of the series—both about his late wife and the difficult, high-profile case that apparently had some issues—continue to intrigue. Gildart Jackson unsurprisingly does a great job as narrator, bringing DC and all of the other characters to life. I recommend the book for fans of procedural crime dramas, especially with a seasoned detective and set in a small-town area of England, and I don’t think you’d really need to start at the beginning of the series.

Find out more about Luck and Judgement

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: But for the Grace

/ Kristi / Leave a comment

But for the Grace
DC Smith #2
by Peter Grainger
read by Gildart Jackson

My rating: 4 / 5
Genre: Detective procedural, mystery

When the resident of a care home dies from a heroine overdose, DC Smith sets out to figure out whether it was murder, suicide…or something in between.

I liked this story overall, with the slower pace, lack of unnecessary flash and fluff, and Smith matching wits with an adversary. Part of what has made this series intriguing to me is the hints dropped here and there that there was a major case in DC’s past that didn’t go well. The shadow hangs over him, along with the shadow of his (somewhat?) recently deceased wife, and I appreciate the little crumbs of both of these situations. Though I’m not sure I quite have a handle on DC yet, that might just be because I made assumptions about him from the beginning based on tropes, and he’s turning out to be more unique than that. I don’t know if the author, then, isn’t putting him across clearly or if it’s my own issue.

I found myself getting lost here or there, either not remembering who some characters were and wishing for a reminder or sometimes due to the Britishness of the story. But overall, this was another good read/listen, and Gildart Jackson unsurprisingly does a great job as narrator. I recommend it for fans of procedural crime dramas, especially with a seasoned detective and set in a small-town area of England.

Find out more about But for the Grace

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!

Book Review: An Accidental Death

/ Kristi / Leave a comment

An Accidental Death
DC Smith #1
by Peter Grainger
read by Gildart Jackson

My rating: 4 / 5
Genre: Detective procedural, mystery

When DC Smith returns to work after being away following a case that went badly, he has to dodge the hints that it might be time for him to retire, because he isn’t ready to give up policework yet. He’s eased back in with busy work, which includes being asked to sign off on an accidental death report that his superior isn’t sure is quite as open and shut as it seems. So Smith begins to investigate, with the aid of a younger detective named Waters, and it turns out there is indeed more going on than meets the eye.

I came across this series when I discovered that it’s narrated by Gildart Jackson, who narrates as series called Fireside Readings that I’ve enjoyed a few of so far. I like his narration style and I like mysteries and police procedurals, so I decided to give this a try. And though I have to admit to being confused or lost here or there in the cultural differences that I didn’t understand, I enjoyed the story overall. DC Smith (DC are his initials, not his rank) is experienced and wise, and his teaming up with the young Waters provides a great dynamic. Smith has recently lost his wife, which gives the story some heart that I appreciated. Smith is a pretty rounded character and not just a procedural-detective cliche. So overall, I enjoyed the story quite a bit, and Gildart Jackson unsurprisingly does a great job as narrator. I’ll definitely be continuing this series and recommend it for fans of procedural crime dramas, especially with a seasoned detective and set in a small-town area of England.

Find out more about An Accidental Death

See what I’m reading next.

If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!