In episode 31, we review all 3 books of the Summoner trilogy—The Novice, The Inquisition, and The Battlemage—young adult fantasy by Taran Matharu.
Also available on Spotify:
Spoiler notice: The following review may contain some spoilers for the previous books in the series, starting with The Inheritance Games.
Avery Kylie Grambs is now only weeks away from inheriting the huge estate left to her by a stranger, but not only does she still have to live at Hawthorne House for the rest of that time in order to inherit, she has to survive. When a stranger shows up asking for help, Avery Kylie Grambs may not trust her, but she can’t stop the Hawthorne brothers from forming their own opinions—opinions which may or may not lead to destruction. A very risky gamble.
I wasn’t a huge fan of the first 2 books in the series, but I pressed on for my daughter, who considers this one of her favorite books series ever. That is mostly because I was not a fan of the love triangle/romance angle in the first 2 books, which was based way more on physical attraction than I prefer and involved Avery Kylie Grambs toying with the hearts of 2 brothers. In the first couple of books, I assumed Avery Kylie Grambs was going to end up with Grayson Davenport Hawthorne, if only because of romance tropes I’m used to, so I was surprised that she “chose” Jameson Winchester Hawthorne by the end of book 2. I thought that would mean that there would be a lot more angsty romance stuff in this book, but fortunately, it wasn’t as bad as I expected (not that there wasn’t some, though, including weird flashbacks to a scene that I figured I must have forgotten in book 2 but turned out to not actually be in book 2 and eventually, after teasing us about it several times, was shown in its entirety in book 3). But that means that I was able to enjoy this third book more for the puzzles and investigation, which were always the main draw of this series for me.
Though this ended up being my favorite book of the series, I still didn’t love it, and that has a lot to do with the fact that I started to strongly dislike Avery Kylie Grambs in this book. And Grayson Davenport Hawthorne. Though I liked Jameson Winchester Hawthorne more, so I guess the brothers part evens out some. (I still think they’re all ridiculous though). Xander, who has been my favorite Hawthorne brother throughout the series, retains his place and actually has an arc in this book that was one of my favorite things about the series.
Here at the end of the main series, I have to say that I am not much of a fan of Jennifer Lynn Barnes’s style. Both her prose style and her overall plotting style. In my review of the previous book, I mentioned that we seem to get an answer for why Tobias Hawthorne left his entire estate to Avery Kylie Grambs, who was a complete stranger to him, making it a very risky gamble, but in the 2nd book, we’re given a different reason, but with half the book to go, we find out that that actually isn’t the reason either, and by the end, I didn’t know if any answers given in that book were “final” or not. Yeah, no, they’re not. It’s one thing to let a story or mystery stretch over 3 books, but it’s a whole other thing to give “fake” answers along the way that are discounted in the next book. I just do not care for that. As for her writing style, if you were at all confused or annoyed by my usage of full names throughout this review, then you understand my feelings. This is not the only time I’ve seen/heard full (either first and last or even first-middle-last) names used in what is supposed to be a romantic setting, and I’d heavily dispute whether there is actually any romance in that. But here, it’s used all through the story, including by the villain, and I’m sure that’s not supposed to be romantic. Even besides that, Barnes has a tendency toward repetition, with phrases, scenes, etc. Like “a very risky gamble” being overstated to death by the end of this book.
I haven’t decided yet if I’m going to continue with the series that follows this one or the bridge book. Part of me feels like it could be better, because the love triangle will be behind us and Avery is in them less, but part of me feels like it could be a waste of time if my other issues with these books persist. I’m interested in one of Barnes’s earlier series, so I may read some of that to see if I can handle reading her books outside of this trilogy. As for this book and series though, I think most people probably won’t be bothered by the same things as me and would enjoy this more than I did. But if you struggle with high-angst love triangles or a love triangle involving siblings (or the normalcy of people who barely know each other sleeping together, which I didn’t even get into in my review), you might want to pass on the story.
Find out more about The Hawthorne Legacy
If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!
NaNoWriMo is short for National Novel Writing Month. It was started in 1999 and grew into a far-reaching event over the next 25 years. To put it briefly, it was a personal challenge to write 50,000 words in 30 days during the month of November. Signing up on the website gave participants somewhere to track their progress, earn goodies for winning (mostly downloadable badges and printable certificates, as well as discounts on some writing- or publishing-related sites), and a huge community of like-minded people, cheering each other on. The main event took place in November, with smaller “camp” events in April and July in later years.
I participated in NaNoWriMo for the first time in 2007, and proceeded to participate every year but 3 (skipping 2008, 2010, & 2011) up until my last, in 2021. I would get excited in September, start planning in October, and then start writing like mad at midnight on November 1. I was a HUGE fangirl. I told everyone I knew about it and tried to get people to participate (whether they thought of themselves as writers or not). After I started this blog in 2014, I proceeded to blog about NaNo a LOT. Every year except 2016 (a rough NaNo for many reasons), I blogged my way through the month, posting daily about my word count and the story I was writing. I’ve also posted a lot of other things about NaNo, including a series of posts giving tips and tricks for getting through the month and even prompts to help someone come up with an idea of what to write. All told, there are almost 500 posts on my blog that have the NaNoWriMo tag—out of around 1900 total posts, that’s about 1/4 of this blog! The point is that NaNoWriMo was a HUGE part of my life.
Then came the screeching end for me. I didn’t gradually drop off, find myself without time to participate, or just run out of ideas to write about. It was a difficult, painful, sad decision, not to be too dramatic about it. It came when the people who ran the event overstepped in a big way. In May of 2022, they sent out an email lamenting the overturning of Roe v. Wade and encouraging everyone to donate money to pro-abortion organizations. I’d always known that the folks behind NaNo were very liberal, and for anyone who hasn’t read enough of my blog to know my own stance, I am a Bible-believing Christian. I was able to ignore some of the progressive stances they were taking, but this one was too much to look past. I felt that continuing to participate and support these people would be turning a blind eye to the encouragement of the murder of innocents.
Though I still didn’t decide immediately to put an end to my participation in NaNoWriMo. At first, I took to social media to see if there was any other outcry in response to this email. And indeed, I did see one or two people comment on the posts that NaNoWriMo had put out with the same information about their pro-abortion stance, those comments very politely voicing unhappiness at not only the general content of the email, but also a specific note that I had missed. From the email/post:
“We (NaNoWriMo) have made an organizational contribution to [the National Network of Abortion Funds’s official ActBlue page].”
Understand that NaNoWriMo was a non-profit organization. Their money came from donations and merchandise sales. I am not a wealthy person by any means, but I had bought a t-shirt every year that I participated (in some cases, 2 shirts), purchased posters, notebooks, a hoodie, and even outright donated a couple of times. This meant that they had taken the money given to them by fans and participants (including plenty of anti-abortion people just like me) that was meant to promote literacy and run this awesome program every year and used it for something completely unrelated to their sphere of influence and worse yet, something that they had every reason to believe a good chunk of the people who gave them that money would not support.
I added my comment to at least one of these posts stating that I was displeased as well and that I might not be able to participate in NaNoWriMo anymore…and then within a day or so of commenting, I went back to the post to find that the comments against their post had been deleted. They made it clear that they didn’t want to discuss our issues with their misuse of our donations. And that’s what clenched my decision to not participate ever again. I couldn’t support an organization that would so blatantly disregard the beliefs and concerns of its participants and donators.
When November came that year, I mourned my loss. NaNoWriMo had been a huge part of my life for over 10 years. I’d won every single year I’d participated (just winning means reaching 50k words) and many years I’d written 25k-50k more than the required words. I finished many first drafts thanks to NaNo, a couple of which I’ve gone on to polish and publish. I pushed myself in so many different ways, learning something about myself as a writer, storyteller, time manager, or something else every single year. I had moments of epic triumph and moments of disappointment. I met people that I never otherwise would have and promoted other people’s artistic outputs related to NaNoWriMo. Fall used to be my favorite time of year, with NaNoWriMo giving way to Thanksgiving and then Christmas. I was jazzed for months!
A few days ago, I learned that NaNoWriMo no longer exists. It came to an end earlier this year. I’m not interested in getting into all of the whys and wherefores, though there are a lot of places out there where this information (possibly with varying degrees of accuracy) can be found, but overall, it appears that the people behind NaNoWriMo made a lot of poor decisions, which sadly doesn’t surprise me. I do wish I’d known about this sooner (I don’t know why I stopped receiving emails, since I didn’t close my account and certainly didn’t make waves in the corporate offices when I stopped participating) so I could have maybe taken some screenshots of the graphs, badges, updates, etc. from my account on the site, though thankfully I chronicled a lot of my participation on both Facebook and this blog. Overall, though I’m sad for other Wrimos, the closure doesn’t really affect me much. If anything, makes it a little less sad that I won’t be thinking of NaNo going on next month without me.
I did try to do my own personal challenge the first few Novembers after this happened, but it was never the same. Of course, that’s partly because my writing work in the last few years has been all revision and not much new writing. (To be honest, I had run out of first-draft ideas and wasn’t sure what I was going to write for 2022’s NaNo anyway.) But I do sometimes challenge myself to work for a certain amount of time every day in November. Now that NaNoWriMo is gone, though, it seems to have opened the door for other organizations to run their own similar novel-writing events.
For anyone who might be interested, I have come across one so far, but I’m sure there are plenty more out there: Novel November Note: this site seems to be selling some kind of product for writers, but it is not my intention to endorse their product, about which I know nothing. I may try it this or another one this November, because I have been itching to write something new, but I’d have to do so alongside revising the book I’m close to being ready to publish. Combined with having no idea what I’d write (I am not a pantser) it doesn’t seem feasible, but I haven’t given up yet. It’s just nice to know that this is something I might be able to do again someday, even if not this year.
Are you a past Wrimo? Whether yes or no, do you think you might participate in some kind of novel-writing challenge this November?
I think I’m starting to get burnt out on this series. I spend a lot of time while listening to these books guessing at reasons why each different character could be the murderer. But not using logic and reason within the story, rather I try to figure out which is the least likely or the one that will surprise the me the most, and then try to figure out how and why they might have done it. I’m usually wrong. I’m not sure if enough information is given to the reader to allow us to truly use logic and reason to pinpoint the killer, but even if it were, I’ve never been great at guessing mysteries correctly anyway. That said, I did have a correct guess about the killer in this book, but that’s partly because I’ve been waiting for this particular outcome for several books now.
I did like the overall mystery in the end, and Poirot is in fine form. I miss Hastings though. And I’m noticing more and more than he goes through several “possible” reveals before he gets to the final one, and by the time he gets to the final one, I’ve got mental whiplash. I think he’s telling us the truth, but that’s not it…then maybe it’s this, but no…it’s not. Because of the aforementioned waiting for this type of killer to come up, I know I’ll never forget the outcome of this book, but with others like that, I can’t really remember who ended up being the bad guy. In the end, I liked the book, but maybe I would’ve liked it more if I weren’t listening to them all so closely together. Still, I think this story is worth reading—or listening to the narration by Hugh Fraser, which is as great as ever.
Find out more about Hercule Poirot’s Christmas
If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!
This will be the cover for my third full-length novel, book #3 in the Pithea series, which will most likely be released early next year. I’ll post about that when it gets closer. Below is the synopsis for the book:
For as long as Alexander Surett can remember, he’s planned to be a bounty hunter like his dad, bringing in criminals to stand trial. And when he gets his first taste of Power usage, he knows that the Power is what he will use to chase those criminals. But during the years-long training on the way to that goal, he stumbles onto an innocuous item from his dad’s past that leads him to question everything he’s been told. Soon it becomes clear that his family’s past tragedy is only the tip of the iceberg.
He brings his unwitting training partner, a Cleric named Leahna Isa, along on his search for answers, and together they attract the unwanted attention of the leader of a band of mercenaries. Rusalki Morano doesn’t like to be told “no,” and the consequences will have devastating effects on both Alexander’s and Leahna’s families—and all of Pithea.
Twelve-year-old Benjamin Broderick is into puzzles and random knowledge. Eighteen-year-old Ethan Broderick is into sports and girls. These brothers don’t have much in common and aren’t very close, and it won’t get any better once Ethan leaves for college in the fall. Though being coerced into taking a road trip together isn’t how Ethan wants to spend the beginning of his summer, he can’t deny that the perks might just be worth it. Especially when Benjamin wins them a chance at a million-dollar prize, and all they have to do is work together to solve a series of puzzles set up by the eccentric puzzle purveyor, Ms. Pennypickle—before their competition beats them to it.
This book was a lot of fun overall to read. I really felt for Benjamin, who keeps trying to connect with his brother without being pushy. And Ethan isn’t mean or bad, he’s just an 18-year-old about to go out into the world and not exactly thinking about how his little brother fits into his life anymore. There were parts to this book that felt a little too convenient or coincidental or just unrealistic, but it all made sense in the end, and in a way that I really enjoyed. There’s a twist to this book that I didn’t see coming, and then a second, smaller twist that I anticipated, based on the first twist, though that doesn’t mean I wasn’t happy to be right. It actually reminded me of one of my favorite movies, but to even say what that movie is would be a spoiler for this book, to those who know the movie.
The book has a lot of interesting trivia in it, especially about Route 66, introducing me to locations that I’ve never heard of and probably never would have, but I have to admit that it made me want to take a road trip to experience some of these places. There is also plenty of humor and a fun shout-out to Grabenstein’s much-loved Lemoncello series. And speaking of that, I appreciate Grabenstein wanting to go in a new direction from that popular series yet still wanting to include puzzles in this book. I felt there was more diversity in puzzle types in this book, and I really liked trying to solve some of them along with the characters. And while it’s difficult to avoid comparing Ms. Pennypickle with Mr. Lemoncello, due to them both being eccentric, rich, genius puzzle creators, I noted some personality differences in Ms. Pennypickle that made her her own person. And the story focuses more on family and relationships than the end goal. I don’t know that this book can become a series, but I do hope Grabenstein continues to write puzzle-filled, adventurous books like this. I really recommend this book for kids around 8-12, and for parents too—any age, really, especially those who like games.
Thank you to Netgalley and Random House Children’s Books for providing me a copy of this book to review.
Find out more about Ms. Pennypickle’s Puzzle Quest
If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!
Spoiler notice: The following review will contain spoilers for the series that precedes it: The Maze Runner series.
Seven decades after the events at the end of The Death Cure, the final book in the previous series, the lives of the descendants of those who were sent to an island to live in peace and safety are disrupted. A ship appears bearing a woman who insists that some of them need to come back to the mainland with her. Meanwhile, the 3 parts of a mysterious authority group called the Godhead are at odds with each other.
I don’t think I’ve ever finished a book and felt like I was given so little info as I did at the end of this book. Things happened, but ultimately, nothing happened. It was a 250-page set-up for whatever is going to come later, but all that happened here is that we’re given little tiny bits of info that don’t really amount to a whole picture of anything. People are taken by one faction, then another, then another, and in the end, I have no idea who is with who and who is good or bad.
I don’t actually remember a lot about the end of the main series, but I remember that I felt like James Dashner had gone off the rails. The first book was good, but things just went all sorts of weird directions after that. This is basically a continuation of that. I decided to give this continuation series a try because of how much I liked The Maze Runner (the first book, not the entire series) and hoped maybe we could get back to those somewhat simpler roots. That is definitely not what we have here. One good thing, though, is that this first book makes it pretty clear that Dashner has plotted the entire continuation trilogy from the get-go, which is not at all what I feel like happened with the first trilogy. It seemed like he wrote the first one, was pleased it went well, and then just pantsed the rest of the trilogy. This feels like the opposite so far, but the first book doesn’t seem to have its own story goal that gets resolved, at least nothing I can pick out, which explains why I felt like nothing really happened.
I’m going to continue this series, but only because I jumped the gun and requested an ARC of the 3rd book in the trilogy. Since it’s one long story, I can’t exactly just skip the middle book. I do hope it gets better, but at this point, I wouldn’t really recommend the book to anyone, whether you’ve read the original trilogy or not. (On the other hand, if you enjoyed the first trilogy, that probably means that what bothered me about it doesn’t bother you, so there’s a decent possibility that you’ll enjoy this book more than me.)
Find out more about The Maze Cutter
If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!
Hiccup trains to swordfight and Toothless tries to care about more than fish.
It was easier to evaluate the book for itself this time, since we’re much more removed from the world of the movie (not that the first book was all that similar, but it was enough to make it difficult). The book is overall pretty fun, though I spent a lot of the book wondering why we want a hero who is so incredibly bad at everything he’s expected to be good at. I’m not saying he should be immediately good at everything, but I guess I would just like him to have a win now and then, at least more often than he does and earlier in the book than he does. So far, these books entail Hiccup being bad, defeated, mocked, etc. until the climax, when the situation requires something that he does better than anyone else in the tribe (usually related to brains over brawn). But I just wish there could be a little more to encourage him/us before the end. However, I have to admit that the win he does get made me happy.
David Tennant again does a brilliant job narrating, though his voice for one particular character (while great) may have given me reason to mistrust him more than we might have been meant to. I’ll say it again—if you love the movies and are looking for books like that, I don’t necessarily recommend you read these books. But it’s overall a fun, short read, though I’m hoping to see a change in the formula in future books.
Find out more about How to Be a Pirate
If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!
When reluctant defense attorney Andy Carpenter’s wife Laurie gets caught up in the lives of a family where the husband/dad has been arrested for a cold-case murder, it’s no surprise that Andy ends up with a new client.
Is it weird that I could probably put the same basic synopsis at the front of every one of these reviews and repeat the same opinions on many of them, and yet, I still absolutely love this series? Some are better than average and some are worse than average, but it’s a formulaic series, so it’s difficult to think of anything new to say with each review. For this book, though, I can say that it was nice to have a less complex and widespread mystery. Not that there weren’t still quite a few players behind the scenes that caused me to get lost a little bit, but overall, I’d say this book was on the high side of average for the series. A solid addition to the series. I especially recommend the audiobook, because Grover Gardner’s narration is a huge part of why I never want to stop listening to this series.
This book also births a spin-off series (though it looks like it was a short-lived one), which I’ve known existed but never really known much about. Now I’ll have to be sure to get that a try too!
Find out more about Dachshund Through the Snow
If you’ve read this book, or read it in the future, feel free to let me know what you think!